Showing posts with label rationalizing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rationalizing. Show all posts

Saturday, August 14, 2010

story-truth vs. happening-truth - TTTC

It's time to be blunt. I'm forty-three years old, true, and I'm a writer now, and a long time ago I walked through Quang Ngai Province as a foot soldier. Almost everything else is invented. But it's not a game. It's a form."
(p. 171)

In "Good Form", O'Brien wants to make it very clear that what he (or anyone else says) happened and what actually happened are very different. but I'm still left a little confused. how can he honestly say "Yes, I killed a man" and at the same time honestly say "Of course not"? is it because there is that separation between what actually happened and what he remembers? is it because he has purposely forgotten the true event? or is this just more rationalizing on his part?

according to the excerpt, it's really not any of those. it's not a game to see who can create the most elaborate story, it's just how things are done. stories are fabricated. they are re-told. they are warped. and somehow, they become some part of the truth. they become the story-truth. the happening-truth gets hidden. it's a perfectly orchestrated cover-up that no one can or will discover.

easier said than done? - TTTC

"Even now I haven't finished sorting it out. Sometimes I forgive myself, other times I don't. In the ordinary hours of life I try not to dwell on it."
(p. 128)

in "Ambush", too, O'Brien uses a definite flashback. only in this flashback, he focuses more on his own thoughts and less on the physical aspects. he focuses less on the man he killed and more on the situation. the war, this event, caused him more confusion and made things even more difficult to sort out. he wonders from time to time what would have happened, but still there's no "rewind". the "comforting" words of Kiley (basically, "he'd've been killed anyway") are no consolation for O'Brien, a man who seems to want to be able to tell his daughter that he's never killed anyone.

he seems to rationalize in this flashback. there's more "well, I just wanted to scare him off" and even a "he had warning" to try to justify what happened. this all, of course is absolutely human, but in order to fully forgive himself, he knows he'll have to fully accept whatever did happen on that trail outside My Khe.