Showing posts with label Jake. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jake. Show all posts

Thursday, August 12, 2010

POV - TSAR

"The three of us sat at the table, and it seemed as though about six people were missing."
p. 228

it's interesting how empty a room can feel when only a handful of people leave. it's like at a party with sixty people, if the ten people you've been hanging out with leave, the party might as well be empty. those other forty-nine may or may not notice that anything has changed, but for the person involved, everything changes.

that's the biggest sense I've gotten with this book. as a separate reader, detached from the story, one can't help but be bored, lost, and confused by it. the story never seems to go anywhere unless one places themselves INTO the story. it's for this reason that a third-person or objective POV would never work in this sort of story. it MUST be in first-person. the reader must be inside the head and mindset of one of the characters and place themselves with all of the others as the story is told. if not for this, nothing ever changes and the whole story means nothing. that emotion is never there, and that emotion is vital to the whole story.

wait, so who's a pimp? - TSAR

Cohn basically beats the crap out of Romero, the bullfighter. but first, he beats the crap out of Jake for being a... wait a second, a pimp? because he let Brett leave with Romero? shouldn't Mike be the one angry? not Cohn? but then again, Cohn's the one still "in love" with Brett. Jake's gotten over her ("to hell with you, Brett Ashley" p. 152) and now NO ONE likes Cohn anymore... but then we see some real remorse from Cohn. Jake goes to check on him (p. 198) and he's crying. he's so upset about what he's done and he has this conversation with Jake:
"You were the only friend I had, and I loved Brett so."
"Well, so long."
"I guess it isn't any use. I guess it isn't any damn use."
"What?"
"Everything. Please say you forgive me, Jake."
"Sure, it's all right."
"I felt so terribly. I've been through such hell, Jake. Now everything's gone. Everything."
"Well, so long. I've got to go."
p. 198

I drawn two important things from this: one, Jake doesn't really seem to care much. he doesn't explicitly forgive Cohn which either means that he was never offended by him OR that he can't forgive him yet, if ever.
the second thing, Cohn says he's lost EVERYTHING now... does that mean he's lost his wife, too? is he leaving her, the opposite?

parties and foils (no, this isn't fencing) - TSAR

Jake misses the first running of the bulls in Pamplona because he's sleeping. he's so tired that he doesn't hear the partying going on outside and only wakes up when a rocket explodes to release the bulls. Imagine this for me, dear reader: being in Pamplona during the running of the bulls AND just after Spain's won their first World Cup in HISTORY. it'd be nuts... no one would sleep. I was in a tiny pueblo when I was there and I still couldn't sleep for three days there was so much activity. I didn't even have the running of the bulls to keep me up either. (though those were interesting to watch on TV).

also, how rude is it for Brett to be gushing over Romero ("My God! he's a lovely boy, and how I would love to see him get into those clothes..." p. 181) while her fiancé is sitting right next to her? I mean really, how little tact do you need to do such a thing? her attitude/personality is really starting to bother me. I would definitely call her a foil though. she contrasts Jake (who I would definitely call the main character) in nearly every way. sure, the two are friends, but when it comes to behavior and morals and actions, Brett does without thinking. Jake's more of the thinking type.

payment, metaphor style - TSAR

"I thought I had paid for everything. Not like the woman pays and pays. No idea of retribution or punishment. Just exchange of values. You gave up something and got something else. Or you worked for something. You paid some way for everything that was any good... Either you paid by learning about them, or by experience, or by taking chances, or by money. Enjoying living was learning to get your money's worth and knowing when you had it. You could get your money's worth. The world was a good place to buy in. It seemed like a fine philosophy."
Jake, to himself, p. 152

this quote really stuck out to me when I read it. not only is it strikingly beautiful in the simplicity of it, but it's got a lot of truth to it. in this part, the world is metaphorically linked to the stock market or a business endeavor: one has to "buy in" to be a part of it. in order to reap the full benefits of the final product, some part of one's property, be it intellectual or physical or emotional, must be spent in order to really be living. it's so true that in order to be fully living, there are sacrifices that must be made. no person can go through life without sacrificing some small part of themselves. again, Hemingway has presented yet another timeless aspect in life: nothing is free.

(bull)fights and zombies - TSAR

Chapter thirteen is interesting. quite interesting. of course there's drinking, but this time Mike (why is he sometimes Mike and sometimes Michael?) gets a little out of hand and starts verbally attacking Robert for all kinds of things, mostly for hanging around Brett: "Tell me, Robert. Why do you follow Brett around like a bloody steer? Don't you know you're not wanted? ... Why do you follow Brett around? Haven't you any manners? How do you think it makes me feel?" (p. 146,7) which sounds mostly like the alcohol caused him to finally let his jealousy show, but Brett (and almost everyone else) seems to back him or not say anything to stop him except, "you're drunk". However, true to form, when they separate the two and then meet up later, they both pretend that nothing's wrong. reminds me of a Blink-182 song: "...and I'll smile, and you'll wave; we'll pretend it's okay. the charade, it won't last..."
and it really is a charade. almost everything in this book is a charade of some sort. the characters never really fully express themselves and the only one you get a true sense of personality from is Jake (because we're in his head, too, just like zombies. [the Cranberries, anyone?])

and FINALLY, the first bullfight. not that I like 'em, I'm actually very against them, but there was talk of them, and I was waiting for the first one in the book.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

character and characterization - TSAR

I'm feeling a little wholesome characterization time. yay!

since this:
"Should we answer it?"
"We might as well, there's no need for us to be snooty." (p. 133)


is the closest we get to direct characterization, I'd say that everything's going by indirect characterization. it hasn't been stated explicitly how a person is, so they're being characterized by their actions, what they say, and by describing them in other ways that aren't character traits.

so far, I'm feeling that Jake's sort of a static character. I'm not seeing him change much. he's basically always the level-headed mediator.
I can't really classify the others because they're not always there like Jake is.
Brett could be round or dynamic, but I'm not sure which. I'm not sure if she's really going to change that much, but she never seems to be the same. at the same time, I'm not positive if she's got multiple dimensions, but she seems pretty real, as in, I can relate to her in some way. not in the (lack of) morals sense, but it's not hard to picture her as a real person.

expatirate = hipster? - TSAR

"You're an expatriate. You've lost touch with the soil. You get precious. Fake European standards have ruined you. You drink yourself to death. You become obsessed by sex. You spend all your time talking, not working. You are an expatriate, see? You hang around cafés." p. 120


sounds like the a hipster to me.. haha. let's consult urbandictionary.com, shall we? : hipster, noun: aged indie kids, still maintain the air of snobbery, still shop at salvation army, and still have a completely astonishing array of knowledge when it comes to obscure music, pop-culture non-sequiturs, and political sneers. Absolutely a blast to be friends with, hell to be enemies of, hipsters are the most bi-polar of all the stereotypes when it comes to how they treat you. yep. basically a hipster.

so, Bill thinks that Jake's a hipster (how awful!), but also thinks that the Civil War was about Lincoln being homosexual. also, sex explains everything. how insightful. you're brilliant, Bill. brilliant. not quite an aphorism, seeing as how it's not a general truth that you've shared, but there could be some real symbolism here, if you want to be completely politically incorrect.

irony and pity - TSAR

"Aren't you going to show irony and pity?"
I thumbed my nose.
"That's not irony."
p. 118

this whole "irony and pity" thing really confuses me. it doesn't make sense. I even tried to make sense of it. what is "irony" according to Bill? because I'm pretty sure it's not "a discrepancy between appearances and reality". is it sort of like Alanis Morisset's song "Isn't it Ironic?", a song that contains very few examples of irony and many coincidences?

and, obviously, this gives me a perfect opportunity to address the irony I've come across in this book. the best example I've found I've already discussed a little in a previous post, but not in terms of the irony. the conversation between Jake and Bill about trying to remember what happened on Bill's trip I find to be quite ironic. I mean, Bill was so drunk that he still can't remember what happened. to try to remind him, Jake makes him drink. as far as I'm aware, alcohol doesn't help much with your memory. somehow, in this book drinking is a way to remember things, not a way to forget them. so maybe that's some sort of satire on Hemingway's part? or he just finds it humorous. I'm not sure...

oh, the wonderful world of dialect... - TSAR

"Tight, Jake. I was tight"
"That's strange. Better have a drink."

conversation between Bill and Jake, p. 76

I'm not gonna lie, it took me a while to realize that "tight" meant "drunk". a long time. actually, I think I had to re-read it a few times to figure it out. I think that in any other circumstance, this would be a little sad. but, I've never heard the word "tight" used in this sense before. I can't say for sure that only this group of people use it, but it certainly isn't something that is used today. at least, not where I'm from. I'm definitely labeling that as dialect.

I also find it hugely amusing that Bill basically says "I was too drunk to remember anything, so I thought it was better than it really is," and Jake's suggestion to jog his memories is "Oh, that's strange, drink some more, maybe you'll remember."

so, Bill gets drunk again. tells everyone what he's going to gift them (he is a taxidermist, after all), meets Brett, and that's about it?
more drinking. more promiscuity from Brett. aaand, not much else? cool.

chapter five and all I can think about is Harry Potter - TSAR

with names like Krum and Woolsey, I can't help it! I mean, Krum IS a HP character and Woolsey is dangerously close to Weasley (especially when you read it quickly). so this blog is going to be a little scattered. I'm pretty sure these names have no real role in the story though. ha.

Cohn comes into the picture again. and he asks Jake questions about Brett, but they're not the kind of questions one asks just to be curious. it's almost as if he knows something more about her than Jake does and he wants to see what Jake knows about her. Cohn kinda flips when Jake suggests that she's a little bit of a floozy, which makes this idea more apparent to me. (secret looooooovers?!)

Jake thinks that she's married before (oh, yeah, she's already married and waiting for a divorce to marry Michael. not lookin' so good moral-wise, Miss) without love and is about to do it again. does he love her? I'm not sure, still.

here's how the last part of it goes down:

"I don't believe she would marry anybody she didn't love."
"Well, she's done it twice."
"I don't believe it."
"Well, don't ask me a lot of fool questions if you don't like the answers."
"I didn't ask you that."
"You asked me what I knew about Brett Ashley."
"I didn't ask you to insult her."
"Oh, go to hell."
... "You've got to take that back."
p. 47

Cohn and Jake are good friends, I suppose, but Jake doesn't seem to be so keen on this. why not?

the lovely Lady Ashley - TSAR

I had already met Brett when I finished the last post, but figured it would be better to address her in this one. first, who the heck is she? she shows up while Jake is having a drink with Georgette, but we don't really ever find out their relation. it appears to be somewhat romantic, but not exactly. second, I find her to be very contradictory. she says that she finds being in love to be "hell on earth" (p. 35), yet she's engaged. she won't let Jake kiss her when they're in the car because she "can't stand it" because she "turns to jelly" (p. 34), but when she leaves him for the night she kisses him. she seeks Jake out again, despite her having a fiancé, but brings another man with her too.
I'm not seeing her as someone with real high moral standards right now, but I can't quite figure her out beyond that. she definitely can't seem to be tied down to one man. let alone be "in love" with only one.